Why Warners Shouldn’t Make More Lord of the Rings Movies

Warner Bros. Discovery I will make more films inspired by Lord of the Rings. This news came in the context of the company’s restructuring. A few months ago, he talked about the possibility of using old franchises to use them again. This process has already begun.

If a cinematic and written work Lord of the Rings, may be one of the most important works of art of mankind. Not only because books J. R. R. Tolkien accompanied thousands of readers fascinated by fantastic stories, but also because the adaptation Peter Jackson It can be considered one of the best trilogies in the history of cinema.

This makes any project related to Lord of the Rings arouse both interest and suspicion. The first one explains that there is always a curiosity to see a new adaptation related to this universe. The second, in this case, has to do with the feeling that the development of new films is less about cultivating the story and the franchise than it is about commercial goals.

More films about Lord of the Rings

Warner Bros. Discovery hasn’t shared many details about this initiative. The well-known idea is to explore stories that were proposed in a trilogy directed by Peter Jackson but weren’t considered. That is, before moving on to a particular section of the books, the immediate reference would be a cinematic work.

It doesn’t seem like an easy task. Not only because of the narrative task involved, but also because, as of August 2022, hug group has power over Enterprises of Middle-earthcompany responsible for studying intellectual property Lord of the Rings and from hobbit. In particular, Embracer Group manages the rights Lord of the Rings through another company free mode.

The CEO of the latter company, Lee Ginchard, explained the following regarding the new film initiative:

“We understand the value of these works, and by working together with our partners in Cinema New Line And Warner Bros.., we intend to honor the past, look to the future and maintain the highest levels of quality and manufacturing values.”

Lee Ginchard

The bet is exciting. But is it possible to achieve? The most recent precedent calls for caution.

hobbit And rings of powerunsuccessful attempts

After Lord of the RingsPeter Jackson has embarked on another great project inspired by J.R.R. Tolkien: the trilogy hobbit. This movie saga explores a story that predates everything that has been shown before. The result was not satisfactory. Perhaps because the memory of previous productions was still very strong, and this could determine the impression of the audience.

last movie about hobbit came out in 2014. Since then, new projects related to mythology Lord of the Rings before rings of powerseries being promoted Amazon Prime Video and released in 2022. So far, the results of this adaptation in the television format are worse than those of the other films mentioned.

The Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power has a powerful setting; it is cinematic, albeit aired in a television format. However, his script is unreliable and leaves unfinished characters and many inconveniences. Added to this is that Amazon Prime Video decided to use some descriptive licenses, which annoyed the followers most committed to the canon. Result? Unusual first season.

Although Warner Bros. Discovery has nothing to do with this Amazon Prime Video project, both failed attempts are already embedded in the collective imagination. This aspect should not be overlooked as the first of the companies mentioned to be exploited by the mythology at a time when perhaps the audience is tired of it due to the discomfort of the aforementioned proposals.

Risk of damage to heritage Lord of the Rings

Lord of the rings, Brotherhood of the ring it was released in 2001. With the beginning of the new century, a franchise came to the film industry, which at that time was not presented as a historical saga. This first part laid the foundations of a story that, through two towers And Return of the Kingits sequels never stopped growing emotionally and epic.

This was a time when social media didn’t have the impact it has today; in which movie tickets were still purchased at the box office, with no digital option, perhaps after checking newspaper listings. Lord of the Ringsas a saga, too, arose at a time when the cinematic experience did not compete with streaming and changes in consumption habits (especially after the COVID-19 pandemic).

Through the saga Lord of the Rings, viewers saw the growth of characters who became attractive figures. Even Gollum, a despicable creature full of envy and hatred, had justification for his desires and ambitions. What happened to him? In the end, it became, like others, a classic pop reference: “My charm!”.

His example reminds us that even on less epic, brilliant and moving occasions, this trilogy has managed to carve out a place in the collective memory. From an epic point of view, battles like the one that happened in Helm’s Deep they can be traced in different productions that took him as a standard; Perhaps the most revealing is the confrontation with the White Walkers that took place in Winterfell during season 8 Game of Thrones.

History weight

back about Lord of the Rings to revive part of this tradition and heritage. At the same time, you have to take on this weight and its impact on the audience. One of the ideas of Warner Bros. Discovery for this new film project is to include Peter Jackson again. He might be a good starting point – chances are no one in the film industry knows the franchise like he does.

However, if this story is constantly exploited with films like Gummies Maker, the greatness of that first trilogy can get lost in all the noise. This is no longer a matter of personal taste. saga of Lord of the RingsMultiple Oscar winner occupies a place in the history of cinema which it would be convenient not to be disrespectful.

Try Amazon Prime Video fully free for 30 days and enjoy the full platform catalog without limits. Just signing up you will have instant access to the best movies and series, as well as free shipping on amazon and other benefits.

That’s the size of the gamble that Warner Bros. Discovery wants to do: to be aware that she may not be doing anything. Lord of the Rings get over that first trilogy and still want to do it, thinking it’s worth it. Probably no. Although in the event that many millions of dollars are generated, all of the above matters little to those in charge of the accounts.